← ANALYST RATINGS · TIPRANKS
Selective Insurance Group (SIGI): analyst forecast and price target
Analyst consensus
Moderate Buy2 Buy3 Hold0 Sell
Ratings of 5 analysts in the last 3 months · top analysts only12-month forecast
Based on 5 price targets given in the last 3 months, the average target is $103, the highest $115, the lowest $90.00. The average is +15.3% from the last price of $89.16.
Analyst ratings 10
| Analyst | Firm | Price target | Rating | Upside | Action | Date | Move vs SPY | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Michael Phillips CFA★★★★★★★★★★#2518 · hits 64% · avg +9.4% | Oppenheimer | $115 | Buy | +29.0% | Reiterated | 13.10.26on TipRanks 07:55 | +0.3%next day +2.3% | ↗ |
| Rowland Mayor★★★★★★★★★★#3491 · hits 72% · avg +7.4% | RBC Capital | $115 | Buy | +29.0% | Reiterated | 12.10.26on TipRanks Oct 13 21:45 | +0.9%next day +0.3% | ↗ |
| Meyer Shields★★★★★★★★★★#72 · hits 75% · avg +14.6% | KBW | $102 → $90.00−11.8% | Hold | +0.9% | Reiterated | 12.10.26on TipRanks 05:15 | +0.9%next day +0.3% | ↗ |
| Bob Huang★★★★★★★★★★#6914 · hits 57% · avg +0.4% | Morgan Stanley | $80.00 | Sell | −10.3% | Assigned | 06.10.26on TipRanks 08:35 | −1.1%next day −1.0% · 5 days +0.5% | ↗ |
| Paul Newsome★★★★★★★★★★#122 · hits 73% · avg +13.9% | Piper Sandler | $105 → $97.00−7.6% | Hold | +8.8% | Reiterated | 28.09.26on TipRanks 07:00 | −0.5%next day −0.3% · 5 days −1.0% | ↗ |
| Rowland Mayor★★★★★★★★★★#3491 · hits 72% · avg +7.4% | RBC Capital | $115 | Buy | +29.0% | Reiterated | 21.09.26on TipRanks 07:30 | −0.3%next day −0.1% · 5 days −2.1% | ↗ |
| AI xAi Insurance - Property and CasualtyxAI Grok-3 | TipRanks - xAI | $112 → $101−9.8% | Buy | +13.3% | Reiterated | 17.09.26on TipRanks 00:05 | — | |
| AI DeepSeek Insurance - Property and CasualtyDeepSeek R1-0528 | TipRanks - DeepSeek | $111 → $98.00−11.7% | Hold | +9.9% | Downgrade | 17.09.26on TipRanks 00:05 | — | |
| AI OpenAI Insurance - Property and CasualtyOpenAI 5.2 | TipRanks - OpenAI | $110 → $98.00−10.9% | Hold | +9.9% | Downgrade | 17.09.26on TipRanks 00:05 | — | |
| AI Anthropic Insurance - Property and CasualtyAnthropic Opus-4.1 | TipRanks - Anthropic | $105 → $96.00−8.6% | Hold | +7.7% | Reiterated | 17.09.26on TipRanks 00:05 | — | |
| AI Google Insurance - Property and CasualtyGemini 2.5Pro | TipRanks - Google | $110 → $100−9.1% | Buy | +12.2% | Reiterated | 17.09.26on TipRanks 00:05 | — | |
| AI PerPlexity Insurance - Property and CasualtyPerPlexity SonarPro | TipRanks - PerPlexity | $113 → $103−8.8% | Buy | +15.5% | Reiterated | 17.09.26on TipRanks 00:05 | — | |
| Unknown Analyst | Oppenheimer | $105 → $115+9.5% | Buy | +29.0% | Reiterated | 14.08.26on TipRanks 21:05 | −1.5%next day −0.2% · 5 days +1.8% | ↗ |
| Meyer Shields★★★★★★★★★★#72 · hits 75% · avg +14.6% | KBW | $101 → $102+1.0% | Hold | +14.4% | Reiterated | 30.07.26on TipRanks 06:56 | −3.8%next day −0.6% · 5 days −1.4% | ↗ |
| Bob Huang★★★★★★★★★★#6914 · hits 57% · avg +0.4% | Morgan Stanley | $80.00 | Sell | −10.3% | Reiterated | 29.07.26on TipRanks 08:23 | +4.0%next day −3.8% · 5 days −5.5% | ↗ |
| Michael Zaremski★★★★★★★★★★#1261 · hits 66% · avg +9.4% | BMO Capital | $97.00 | Hold | +8.8% | Downgrade | 28.07.26on TipRanks 05:20 | +1.5%next day +4.0% · 5 days −1.8% | ↗ |
| No ratings for this filter. | ||||||||
Every rating the collector has kept for the last 12 months, including the earlier ones of the same analyst. Latest of each analyst
Best analysts covering Selective Insurance Group
TipRanks picks them by their record on this stock; the figures under the name are their record across all their ratings.
Most accurate
Most profitable
How the average price target moved
The average target of all analysts (their ratings of the 3 months before) on each day, the top analysts’ dashed, against the price; the site keeps this record since 1 October 2026. On 01.10.26: target $101 at a price of $83.60 (+20.8%); now: $99.00 at $89.16 (+11.0%).
PriceAverage targetTop analysts’ target
Recommendation trend · top analysts
Strong BuyBuyHoldSell
| Rating | 05.26 | 06.26 | 07.26 | 08.26 | 09.26 | 10.26 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Strong Buy | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Buy | 4 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 3 |
| Hold | 4 | 4 | 6 | 5 | 6 | 2 |
| Sell | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Earnings and sales forecast
Next report: 22.10.26 (Q3 2026, date not confirmed)
Earnings per share
Next quarter’s EPS estimate — $1.92 (from $1.53 to $2.23). Last quarter: $1.95.
Sales
Next quarter’s sales estimate — $1.2B (from $1.1B to $1.2B). Last quarter: $1.4B.
Best top-analyst consensus in the sector · Financial
About Selective Insurance Group
- CEO: John Joseph Marchioni
- Employees: 2,800
- 40 Wantage Avenue, Branchville, NJ, 07890, US
- www.selective.com
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI) is a U.S.-based company that delivers a wide array of insurance products and services. Its business operations are structured across four primary divisions: Standard Commercial Lines, Standard Personal Lines, Excess & Surplus Lines (E&S), and Investments. The company's insurance offerings include comprehensive property coverage, safeguarding clients from financial repercussions due to accidental damage to real estate, personal possessions, or the resulting loss of earnings. It also provides casualty insurance, which addresses financial liabilities stemming from employee work-related injuries and third-party bodily harm or property damage. Additionally, flood insurance is a key component of its product suite. Beyond its core underwriting activities, Selective actively manages a diverse investment portfolio. This includes allocating capital to fixed income securities, commercial mortgage loans, equity holdings, and various alternative investments. Selective's insurance solutions are made available to a broad clientele, including corporations, non-profit organizations, local government entities, and private individuals. These products and services are distributed through a network of independent retail agents and wholesale general agents. Established in 1926, Selective Insurance Group, Inc. maintains its headquarters in Branchville, New Jersey.
Data from the stock’s TipRanks forecast page, read 18 min ago. It is read again as soon as a new rating appears and at least every 8 hours. TipRanks ↗